CANADA IS “RIPPING US OFF”

We need to understand trade.

This month Mr. Trump once again said, "Canada has been ripping us off for many, many years and they're not going to rip us off anymore."

Perhaps we need to look at the real numbers.

According to the United State Trade Representative (the official U.S. government agency on trade and trade policy) last year:

Canada exported $334 billion in goods to the U.S.
Canada imported $382 billion in goods from the U.S.

This resulted in a Trade Deficit for CANADA of $48 billion in goods.

Let’s say that once again; Canada paid $48 billion more for goods imported from the U.S. than it received for goods exported to the U.S.

Canada exported $92 billion in services to the U.S.
Canada imported $65 billion in services to the U.S.

This resulted in a Trade Surplus for CANADA of $28 billion in services

The NET RESULT is that Canada had a net Trade Deficit with the U.S. of $20 billion.

If you judge a country as “ripping off” the other because they are purchasing less than they are buying, it is the U.S. that is “ripping off” Canada.

Just to recap, the U.S. had a SURPLUS in its trade with Canada; we exported more to Canada than we bought from Canada.

DRILLING DOWN ANOTHER LEVEL (by per capita consumption)
The population of the US is about 350 million.
The population of Canada is about 42 million.

Just looking at Goods traded, Canada imported $382 Billion from the US.
This amounts to about $9,100 worth of US goods imported per capita in Canada.
On the other hand, the US imported $334 Billion in goods from Canada.
This amounts to about $950 of Canadian goods imported per capita in the US.
Canada imported almost TEN TIMES the amount of goods per person than the US imported from Canada.

And if we look at the total trade between the two countries:
Canada imported a total of $442 Billion in trade FROM the US
This amounts to about $10,600 of imports per Canadian citizen.
On the other hand, the US imported a total of $426 Billion FROM Canada.
This amounts to about $1,200 of imports per each US citizen.

Canada imported almost NINE TIMES the goods and services per person than the US imported from Canada.
Who is benefiting the most here?

It certainly does not seem that Canada is “ripping us off”.

What does Canada export TO the U.S.?

Mineral Fuels and Oils (Crude Oil & Petroleum): $118 billion
Vehicles and Automotive Parts: $47 billion
Machinery, Nuclear Reactors, and Boilers: $32 billion
Plastics: $13 billion
Electrical and Electronic Equipment: $13 billion
Precious Stones and Metals (including Gold): $11 billion
Wood and Wood Charcoal: $10 billion
Aluminum: $10 billion
Aircraft and Spacecraft: $ 8 billion
Pharmaceutical Products: $ 7 billion
And what does Canada import FROM the US?
Vehicles and Auto Parts: $46 billion
Machinery and Industrial Equipment: $39 billion
Mineral Fuels and Oils: $27 billion
Electrical and Electronic Equipment: $14 billion
Plastics and Plastic Articles: $12 billion
Optical, Medical, and Technical Apparatus: $ 7 billion
Pharmaceutical Products: $ 6 billion

We purchase oil from Canada and sell oil to Canada because our refineries need the heavy oil that Canada produces, and our light oil is needed in Canada.

On a per capita basis, the Canadians import more drugs from the US than the US imports from Canada although the gross numbers are equal. And why is this so? Because there are Canadian-owned and Canadian-manufactured pharmaceuticals that US citizens need!

And the Canadians MUST import drugs manufactured by American pharmaceutical companies who own the intellectual and manufacturing rights to those drugs.

We can do the same analysis for services traded between the U.S. and Canada, but I think the points are quite clear. We trade with our neighbors because they have things we need and we have things they need. Period.

The Truth about Trade Deficits and Surpluses

Looking at gross numbers obscures the actual impact on individual citizens.
We are not losing in a “Trade War” with Canada, we are winning, both on a gross basis and on a per capita basis.