WHEN SPIN CROSSES THE LINE AND BECOMES LIES

“Spin” is when a person interprets facts in a way that favors their own perspective. It provides an alternative viewpoint to other interpretations that might be less favorable to yours.

At least, for me, Spin is entirely acceptable. Both sides do it.

A good example was the interview today with Secretary of Energy Chris Wright on This Week with Martha Raddatz.

Secretary Wright was trying to explain the actions Mr. Trump took yesterday to waive the sanctions imposed by the Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act, passed last month and due to take affect tomorrow. The bill provided that the President had the right to pause the sanctions for 60 days to assess the economic impact. Sec. Wright made the argument that the waiver was actually “a carrot to try to end a war.” The “spin” here is that the waiver was actually designed to speed an end to the war, not a way to benefit Russia. It provides a period of reflection for Mr. Putin before the sanctions are put into effect. And to that level I believe that this is a fair justification for the actions. It may not be the interpretation that you make, but the purpose of political spin is to offer a reading of events that meets the objectives of the speaker.

Again, I believe that is totally fair.

However (and you know that I would have a “however”), Secretary Wright did not leave his statement stand. He needed to move past that to add (in the same paragraph), “It’s not an economic lifeline for Russia”, and went on to explain that statement, “or have an ability to repair their refineries, which they only can get to through a peace agreement with Ukraine, an energy ceasefire, or a step towards peace.”

As Secretary of Energy, we can expect Mr. Wright to have a basic understanding of energy resources or at least have a staff that can provide that information to him.

Secretary Wright was appointed to his position after serving as CEO of Liberty Energy, North America’s second largest hydraulic fracturing company. He has served on the boards of Oklo Inc., a nuclear technology company, and EMX Royalty Corp., a Canadian mineral rights and mining rights royalty payment company. It is fair to assume that he has a basic knowledge of the oil industry and its basic chemistry or, at least, he SHOULD have such knowledge.

So, why do I think his statement is false?

A little bit of information here.

There are three grades of Diesel fuel:
Grade #1 is a light, low-viscosity distillate (similar to kerosene). It resists gelling in cold weather making it ideal for use in winter.
Grade #2 is the standard, most common on-road fuel found at gas stations. It offers higher energy and better fuel economy than Diesel #1 but is unfit for cold weather because it can become cloudy, thicken and gel up. Because of these characteristics it is often referred to as “Summer Diesel”.
Grade #4 (there is no Grade #3 available for use) is a heavy, high-viscosity fuel used in power generators, but not suitable for standard uses.

For this discussion, only Grades #1 and #2 are applicable.

Last week, Mr. Trump announced a deal to purchase Diesel fuel from Russia. The waiver of sanctions added to that deal increase the ability of the U.S. to purchase more diesel from Russia.

But…

HOW WOULD THE DIESEL DEAL WITH RUSSIAN AFFECT THE U.S.?

The agreement provided that there would be an immediate shipment of 300,000 metric tons of Diesel fuel from Russia. 300 THOUSAND TONS sounds like A LOT of Diesel, but it really is not. 300,000 tonnes of Diesel fuel is the equivalent of approximately 2.25 million barrels of Diesel fuel, or about 27 million gallons of diesel fuel. The U.S. uses approximately 160 million gallons of diesel fuel per day.

So, the initial shipment of 300,000 tonnes of Diesel fuel is sufficient for about 4 hours of a single day of U.S. consumption.
The agreement also provides for an additional 500,000 tonnes of Diesel fuel in November and 1,000,000 tonnes in the future, with an additional 3,000,000 tonnes if Russia is able to refine it in their own facilities.

This amounts to a total shipment of 1.8 million tonnes of Diesel fuel, with an additional 3.0 million possible.
1.8 million tonnes of Diesel fuel would represent 13.5 million barrels, or 162 million gallons, a little over ONE DAY of the U.S. Diesel fuel use.

And the grand total of “possible” imports, 4.8 million tonnes of Diesel fuel, would be a total of 432 million gallons of Diesel fuel, or JUST UNDER 3 DAYS of U.S. needs.

The effects of such an input to the U.S. energy needs or the U.S. economy would be negligible.

HOW WOULD THE DIESEL DEAL WITH RUSSIAN AFFECT RUSSIA?

More importantly, we need to understand what Russia would be selling to the U.S.
Remember the Grades of Diesel? Russia currently has a surplus of Diesel fuel that they are willing to sell to the U.S.; an opportunity presented to them by Mr. Trump.

But the Diesel fuel they have on surplus is almost entirely Grade #2, “Summer Diesel”. It is already late October, and winter is settling in in Russia. Russians can no longer use Summer Diesel; they MUST switch to Grade #1. The surplus Diesel that Russia has is of NO USE TO RUSSIA. Offloading that surplus to the U.S. frees up their storage facilities and provides revenue that would not have been created if the unusable fuel remained in Russia.

If Russia was even able to produce the additional 3 million tonnes of Diesel fuel imagined in this deal (and that would not happen until next spring at the earliest) 3.8 million tonnes of Summer Diesel from Russia would currently sell for between $4.8 billion and $5.7 billion. And if prices drop after the midterms as Mr. Trump and Mr. Bessent have promised, those numbers will fall precipitously also.
Secretary Wright MUST know these facts. When he says that “The only way Russia gets benefit from this move means they have to export diesel, which means they have to either consume less diesel internally, reduce the war effort.” He knows better. He knows that the Diesel they are sending us is unusable internally and unusable in the winter in the war in Ukraine.

Spinning events to provide legitimate explanations is customary, but lying about the facts needs to be called out.